The 'One Suitcase' Challenge: Could You Live with Less?

The concept of the "One Suitcase Challenge" represents the extreme frontier of minimalism. It is a lifestyle experiment—and for many, a permanent choice—where an individual limits their total physical possessions to what can fit within a single piece of luggage (typically a 40-liter to 100-liter suitcase).

While it may sound like a temporary travel arrangement, the One Suitcase lifestyle is a sophisticated response to the complexities of modern consumerism, the rise of the "asset-light" economy, and the global shift toward remote work. As of 2025, with housing costs at historic highs and the "experience economy" outpacing the "goods economy," this challenge has evolved from a niche subculture into a researched-backed framework for personal efficiency and psychological well-being.

In this comprehensive guide, we will analyze the cognitive science behind decluttering, the economic implications of living small, the environmental benefits of reduced consumption, and the practical steps required to transition into a life defined by experiences rather than objects.

1. The Psychology of Ownership: Why We Accumulate

To understand the One Suitcase Challenge, we must first understand why humans are biologically and culturally programmed to collect items.

The Endowment Effect and Loss Aversion

Research in behavioral economics, pioneered by Daniel Kahneman and Richard Thaler, identifies the Endowment Effect: a phenomenon where individuals value an object more simply because they own it. This is closely linked to Loss Aversion, where the pain of losing an item is psychologically twice as powerful as the joy of gaining one.

In the context of the One Suitcase Challenge, the primary hurdle is not the physical act of discarding items, but the psychological "detachment" required to overcome these cognitive biases.

The Cognitive Load of Clutter

A landmark study by the Princeton University Neuroscience Institute found that a cluttered environment restricts your ability to focus. The researchers discovered that the visual cortex can be overwhelmed by task-irrelevant objects, making it harder to allocate attention and complete tasks efficiently.

2. The Economic Framework of the "Asset-Light" Lifestyle

In 2025, the global economy has shifted significantly toward Access over Ownership. This shift makes the One Suitcase Challenge more feasible than it was a decade ago.

The Rise of the Sharing Economy

The "One Suitcase" practitioner relies on a global infrastructure of shared goods. Instead of owning a car, a lawnmower, or a library of physical books, they utilize:

• Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS): Ride-sharing and short-term rentals.
• SaaS and Cloud Computing: Eliminating the need for physical media (DVDs, CDs, external hard drives).
• Furnished Rentals: The growth of platforms like Blueground or Landing allows individuals to move with only personal effects.

Financial Implications of Extreme Minimalism

Living with only one suitcase drastically reduces Fixed Costs.

1. Housing: Eliminates the need for large square footage primarily used for storage.
2. Maintenance: Zero costs for furniture repair, appliance maintenance, or home décor.
3. Insurance: Lower premiums when total personal property value is minimized.

Case Study: The Cost of "Stuff" According to 2024 data from the Self Storage Association, the average American spends approximately $160 per month on off-site storage. Over 10 years, that is $19,200 spent simply to keep items the owner does not use daily. The One Suitcase Challenge redirects this capital toward investments or experiences.

3. Environmental Impact: The Sustainability of Less

The One Suitcase Challenge is perhaps the most effective individual contribution to the Circular Economy.

Carbon Footprint and Embedded Energy

Every physical object has "embedded energy"—the total energy required to extract raw materials, manufacture, and transport the product. By limiting possessions to a single suitcase, an individual’s personal carbon footprint regarding "goods consumption" drops by an estimated 70-85% compared to the average Western consumer.

Waste Reduction

The average person in a developed nation generates roughly 4.5 pounds of trash per day. A minimalist lifestyle necessitates a "one-in, one-out" rule. To add a new item to the suitcase, an old item must be sold, donated, or recycled. This creates a natural barrier to impulsive consumption and reduces landfill contributions.

4. The Anatomy of a One-Suitcase Life: Practical Execution

How do you fit an entire life into ~100 liters? It requires a transition from "just-in-case" items to "essential" items.

The 90/90 Rule

Coined by minimalists Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus, the rule states: Look at an object. Have you used it in the last 90 days? Will you use it in the next 90 days? If not, it can go.

The Capsule Wardrobe: 2025 Edition

The wardrobe is usually the largest category of "stuff." A successful One Suitcase traveler utilizes high-performance fabrics.

• Merino Wool: Naturally anti-microbial and odor-resistant; can be worn multiple times without washing.
• Technical Synthetics: Lightweight, moisture-wicking, and quick-drying.
• Layering Systems: Instead of a heavy parka, use a base layer, a mid-layer (fleece), and a shell (rain jacket).

Example Inventory for a 40L Carry-On (The "One Bag" Standard)

Digitalization of the Physical

To live in one suitcase, you must digitize your "legacy items."

• Photos/Documents: High-resolution scanning to secure cloud storage.
• Books: Transition to e-readers (Kindle/Kobo).
• Sentimental Items: High-quality photography of the item can often satisfy the emotional memory without the physical bulk.

5. Advanced Topics: Logistics and Legalities

Living with less is not just about packing; it is about managing the logistics of a mobile or minimalist life.

The "Permanent Address" Problem

In a one-suitcase lifestyle, especially for digital nomads, maintaining a legal domicile is critical for taxes, voting, and banking.

• Virtual Mailboxes: Services like Anytime Mailbox scan your physical mail and provide a PDF, allowing you to manage "paperwork" from anywhere.
• Digital Residency: Programs like Estonia’s e-Residency allow entrepreneurs to run a location-independent business.

Health and Ergonomics

One risk of extreme minimalism is the "laptop hunch." Practitioners must balance their limited gear with physical health. Portable ergonomic tools, such as the Roost Stand or ultra-lightweight Bluetooth keyboards, are considered "essential" despite their space consumption.

6. Critical Perspectives and Misconceptions

While the One Suitcase Challenge offers freedom, it is important to address its limitations through a critical lens.

The "Privilege" of Minimalism

Critics argue that minimalism is a luxury of the wealthy. To own only a few high-quality items (like a $2,000 MacBook and $100 Merino shirts), one must have the financial safety net to replace items if they break or are lost. For someone in poverty, "hoarding" is often a survival strategy against future scarcity.

The Social Cost

Living with one suitcase can lead to social friction. It may be difficult to host friends, engage in hobbies that require gear (like woodworking or skiing), or maintain traditional family structures.

The "Replacement" Fallacy

Some people "minimalize" by throwing away perfectly good items only to buy new "minimalist-branded" versions. This is simply a different form of consumerism. True minimalism focus on utility and longevity.

7. Step-by-Step Transition Guide

If you are considering the One Suitcase Challenge, follow this research-based progression:

Phase 1: The Inventory Audit (Days 1–7)

Don't throw anything away yet. Simply log everything you use for one week. You will likely find that you use only 20% of your possessions 80% of the time (The Pareto Principle).

Phase 2: The "Packing Party" (Days 8–14)

Pack everything you own into boxes as if you were moving. Over the next week, only take out what you actually need. At the end of the week, the items still in the boxes are candidates for removal.

Phase 3: The Digital Migration (Days 15–30)

Scan all essential documents. Move your photo albums to the cloud. Cancel physical subscriptions.

Phase 4: The Final Edit

Choose your suitcase. Research shows that constrained space breeds creativity. By limiting your "container," you force yourself to make the hard decisions about what truly adds value to your life.

8. Summary and Key Takeaways

The One Suitcase Challenge is not about deprivation; it is about optimization. It is a tool to strip away the "non-essential" to make room for what truly matters: focus, freedom, and experience.

Key Takeaways:

1. Mental Clarity: Reducing physical clutter directly correlates with reduced cortisol levels and increased cognitive focus.
2. Financial Freedom: Lowering fixed costs and resisting the hedonic treadmill allows for greater capital accumulation or investment in experiences.
3. Environmental Stewardship: A minimalist footprint is a powerful statement against the "throwaway culture" and reduces individual carbon emissions.
4. Mobility: In a 2025 economy that values agility, living with one suitcase provides the ultimate competitive advantage for career and personal growth.
5. Quality over Quantity: The challenge encourages the purchase of fewer, higher-quality items that last longer, ultimately saving money and reducing waste.

9. References and Authoritative Sources